MLA taxpayer-funded pension plans need reform

MLA pensions should reflect the real world, says guest commenter Jordan Bateman

By Jordan Bateman

With just months until the next provincial election, the lifeboats are starting to fill up as MLAs of both political persuasions look to leave the ship of state.

That means one thing: millions of dollars in pension payouts.

Pension payouts that are primarily funded by taxpayers and taxpayer dollars.

Dave Hayer is one of the more recent Liberal MLAs to announce he won’t seek re-election next May.

He will be retiring after 12 years of elected life.

The Surrey-Tynehead MLA served for a few years as a parliamentary secretary, inflating his best three years of earnings – the cornerstone of a pension calculation.

Hayer’s annual pension will likely start with $47,600 at age 65.

This will be increasing every year to more than $62,900 annually, should he live to be 80 years old.

That works out to a lifetime pension of about $824,000.

On the other side of the aisle, retiring Pitt Meadows-Maple Ridge’s Michael Sather should start with a pension of $28,500 after eight years as an opposition NDP MLA.

His lifetime total will come in slightly under half a million dollars.

Former Attorney General Barry Penner resigned his seat last year after 15 years as an MLA – he will start his retirement at age 65 with an annual pension of more than $78,500.

His lifetime total will exceed $1.35 million.

Kamloops B.C. Liberal MLA Kevin Krueger’s pension, by virtue of his two extra years in office, is even larger.

Krueger’s first year pension payout is likely to be $87,700.

This will be increasing every year to more than $115,700 annually at age 80.

That’s a lifetime pension of about $1.5 million.

Ironically, Krueger and Penner were two of the B.C. Liberal candidates who ran against gold-plated MLA pensions in the 1996 election.

Even though the Liberals lost, the NDP changed the pension rules to make it a much fairer system.

Unfortunately for taxpayers, Premier Gordon Campbell took MLAs back to the gold-plated system in 2007.

He even allowed MLAs to buy back benefits to the richer plan for the years they served from 1996 to 2007.

The extent of that buyback is still shrouded in mystery, and the government has refused to issue a list of MLAs who bought back into the richer plan.

We do know buybacks cost taxpayers more than $20.9 million.

Pension experts tell us that MLAs would be crazy – or incredibly principled – not to have bought back those years.

And indeed we have heard officially of any MLA not buying back in.

Premier Christy Clark bought back her missing years, confirming that fact last year.

Media outlets interviewing retiring MLAs would be well-advised to ask politicians if they bought back into the bigger, predominantly taxpayer-funded pension.

Under the current pension plan, taxpayers contribute $4 for every $1 a politician puts in.

Retiring MLAs too young to start collecting their pensions immediately are eligible for up to 15 months of salary after they leave office.

If an MLA gets a job before the end of the 15 month period, the assistance is terminated.

But if that job has an annual salary below $101,859, the taxpayer is on the hook for the difference.

They can also claim an educational grant of $9,000.

No one is saying politicians shouldn’t have a pension, but MLA pensions should reflect the real world and go back to the 1996 NDP model – invested in a group RRSP and matched dollar for dollar by the taxpayer.

That’s a competitive pension package, and fair for both the MLA and taxpayers.


Jordan Bateman is the British Columbia Director for the Canadian Taxpayers Federation. He previously worked for the Langley Advance newspaper and spent six years as an elected Township Councillor in Langley, B.C.

Just Posted

Terrace Peewees win provincials

The Midgets won bronze and Bantams finished fifth, with the female Midgets still playing

Bigger and safer bridge to be built across the Nass

New two lane bridge will accomodate heavier commercial vehicles

B.C. NDP offers tax breaks to jumpstart LNG Canada in Kitimat

‘We’re not giving away more money,’ Premier John Horgan says

UPDATE: Snowfall warning ended for Hwy 16 – Smithers to Terrace

Cloudy, warmer rain showers are expected to change to snow after midnight.

Terrace runner set to go for Boston Marathon

The 54-year-old Brent Webb has been running only three years, but heads to the elite Boston in April

Vancouver Aquarium’s resident octopus released into ocean

Staff let the Giant Pacific octopus go into the waters near Bowen Island so she can reproduce

How to keep local news visible in your Facebook feed

Facebook has changed the news feed to emphasize personal connections. You might see less news.

Alberta tells B.C. to stop opposing pipelines if it doesn’t like gas prices

John Horgan said he would like to see the federal government step in to deal with high gas prices.

BREAKING: B.C. mother hit in truck rampage dies

Family confirms mother of four Kelly Sandoval dies almost two months after being hit.

Walking from Argentina to Alaska

Holly ‘Cargo’ Harrison is now in northern B.C. on his journey from Argentina to Alaska.

PHOTOS: Students exhibit stunning paper couture dresses

22 paper made gowns will be on display at Vancouver’s Oakridge Centre until March 27

Fatal crash closes Highway 97 south of Prince George

A two-vehicle crash in the Cariboo has claimed the life of one person and sent another to hospital.

BCHL Today: Prince George avoids elimination with game five win

BCHL Today is a (near) daily look at what’s going on around the league and the junior A world.

Suspect arrested and charged for assault on autistic man

Parmvir Chahil has strong B.C. ties; two others charged with accessory after the fact

Most Read