Big nymphs

Columnist Rob Brown channels trout fisherman Charles E. Brooks

Charles E. Brooks, retired US Air Force officer, an avid trout fisherman who loved to fish the rough and tumble rivers of Montana located in the Yellowstone area, had a two pronged problem to solve, namely to invent an imitation of the giant black stone fly nymphs that the rainbow trout would mistake for the real deal, and how to get it down between the big rocks embedded in the bottom of riffles and glides of his home streams using a fly rod.

The Pteronarcys nymphs, some as long as a man’s thumb, most the size of a woman’s, are bottom dwellers that graze atop and between the boulders that decorate stream beds. At times, they unhook themselves from the substrate and go with the flow. These dangerous drifts appear reckless at first, since they leave the bugs naked and vulnerable to trout that dart from their ambuscades like heat seeking missiles and pick them off. Scientists call this behaviour benthic drift, and have devoted a lot of research to it. There are many theories as to why aquatic benthos behave this way. Charlie Brooks pored over the papers published by entomologists with the practical eye of a trout fisher. To Charlie, how the nymphs drifted was more important than why they did.

He learned that most of these drifts occurred at night, which didn’t surprise him since a nocturnal float at least afforded the creatures the cover of low light. Brooks was pleased to discover that benthic drift occurred during the day too, but not as often, and usually on darker days. After a lot of field work, he learned to spot the conditions when benthic drift was happening in broad daylight. During these prime feeding times for trout, Brooks’ imitation needed to be fished near, but not on, the bottom. To this end, he loaded his reel with the fastest full sinking fly line of the time, which, by today’s standards, would be a slow sinking line. On the end of that line, he attached a short length of heavy monofilament, the heavy nylon being necessary to turn over a large heavy fly.

To imitate the stonefly nymphs, Brooks wound an underbody of lead wire on a long shanked streamer hook with a #4 gape. Next, he fastened a pair of small quills from the leading edge of the flight feather from a goose to the bend to ape the tails of the stone nymph. To create  the segmented effect of the insect’s exoskeleton, he wound a body of black mohair, then spiralled some medium copper wire over it in even turns.  Finally, Brooks took a pair of rooster hackles, one brown, the other grizzled, and wound them through the fake bug’s thorax, thus simulating legs and gills.

Out of water, Charlie Brooks’ Montana Stone nymph, didn’t look like much (go to stevenojai.tripod.com and scroll halfway down the screen to see an example), but once it was submersed, it bore an uncanny resemblance to the aquatic invertebrate it was meant to imitate. During his early experiments on the stream, Brooks learned that the fly patterns tied to mimic the yellow and orange undersides of the natural nymph actually spooked trout when they flipped upside down in the turbulence. Consequently, he constructed symmetrical nymphs that always appeared to be riding right side up in the flow whether they were or not.

Of course, coming up with an effective pattern was only half the battle. To best imitate the drifting nymph meant fishing it so that it was free of drag. Drag is fly fishing argot that refers to the pull of leader and line on the fly.  Drag is the bane of dry fly fishers because insects floating atop the water float freely. Since a floating fly is attached to tow rope consisting of tippet, leader, and fly line, the latter is always trying to drag it across the top of the water like a minuscule water skier. Flies behaving this way fail to trip the hair trigger instincts of trout. As a result, the angler fishing dry flies is forever readjusting his line to keep his fly floating freely as long as possible. Brooks’s task was to achieve the same kind of extended free float underwater, a much more difficult feat.

To affect this, he cast a short line upstream just as a dry fly fisher would, retrieved line as the bug drifted toward him, while simultaneously lifting his 8 weight, 9 foot fibreglass rod as the nymph passed him. As the nymph continued its journey downstream, he lowered his rod and began paying out line. When the nymph began to drag, Brooks cast it back upstream with a crisp flick a little farther from the bank than the cast before. The whole technique is like deceptively difficult to do well but once mastered, very effective.

After reading Brooks’s Nymph Fishing for Larger Trout, I devoted a lot of fishing time to his nymphing technique. As Charlie predicted, I caught a lot of trout with it, but it was not until I met Hugh that I realized it had a much broader application.

Continued next week…

 

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Disrespectful that Horgan won’t meet during northern B.C. tour: hereditary chief

Na’moks said he was frustrated Horgan didn’t meet with the chiefs

BC Green Party leader visits Wet’suwet’en camps at heart of pipeline conflict

Adam Olsen calls for better relationship between Canada and First Nations

Another snowstorm expected for Terrace and Kitimat area

Wind is expected up to 80 km per hour

COLUMN | New year, new you: Make those changes stick

Wellness Matters by columnist Joelle McKiernan

Pilot project thins out overgrown forest location

Immediate and long term logging and environmental benefits eyed

After cashing in on QB gambles, Chiefs and 49ers to clash in Super Bowl

KC beats Tennessee, San Francisco dispatches Green Bay to reach NFL title game

How to beat Blue Monday, the most depressing day of the year

Multiple factors can play a role in seasonal depression, says Fraser Health psychiatrist

B.C. VIEWS: Few clouds on Horgan’s horizon

Horgan’s biggest challenge in the remainder of his term will be to keep the economy humming along

Victoria family focuses on ‘letting go, enjoying time together’ after dad gets dementia

Walter Strauss has developed an interest in music and now takes line dancing classes

B.C. forest industry grasps for hope amid seven-month strike, shutdowns, changes

Some experts say this could be worse for forestry than the 2008 financial crisis

Northern B.C. RCMP investigating alleged sexual assault in downtown Smithers

One person was transported by ambulance to hospital following RCMP investigation at Sedaz

UBC, Iranian-Canadian community create memorial scholarship in honour of victims

The Jan. 8 crash killed 176 people, including 57 Canadians

Most Read