Smoking gun missed its mark

The biggest mystery about Rob Brown’s latest column from Sept. 21 is why it so poorly represents the discussions which happened at the Cohen Commission nearly a month ago.

Dear Sir,

The biggest mystery about Rob Brown’s latest column from  Sept. 21 is why it so poorly represents the discussions which happened at the Cohen Commission nearly a month ago.

Apparently in that month Mr. Brown did not read through any transcripts and studies from the week he writes about, even though they are all publicly available online at

The transcripts show that all four scientists tasked with writing technical reports about aquaculture for the commission had to agree, despite their differences, that aquaculture and wild salmon can co-exist. As well, they also had to agree that there was not enough evidence to conclude salmon farms influenced the 2009 Fraser sockeye decline.

If Mr. Brown had done some research before echoing conspiracy theories from the blogosphere, and read the publicly available facts for himself, he would have read how Dr. Kristi Miller was uncomfortable with her work being called a “smoking gun” which could solve the mystery of the 2009 sockeye decline.

“Actually, I had no intent of saying that,” she said (transcript for Aug. 25, 2011 hearing, page 29, line 8). “And I should clarify… what I really meant was that this could be a major factor. Not the major factor, because I also agree with others that there is no single major factor.”

Miller and most other salmon scientists involved with the Commission agree that there was no single factor which led to the 2009 sockeye decline.

In fact, a cumulative impact report which looked at all data gathered for the Commission during the past year concluded there were only two things likely to have had an effect on the Fraser sockeye run: climate change and marine conditions. Not salmon farms or logging or mining or anything else researchers studied. This can be seen in the addendum to technical report six, which is publicly available on the commission’s website.

Hopefully instead of taking Mr. Brown’s speculative and baseless opinion as fact, his readers will research for themselves the science presented at the Cohen Commission, and the transcripts of the discussions.

As for his comments about salmon farms being dirty and a “sin of the first order,” perhaps if he comes to tour a farm for himself he will see that salmon farms in B.C. are clean, highly-regulated and operated by people who care about the environment and wild salmon as much as anyone else in this province.

Grant Warkentin,

Mainstream Canada,

Campbell River, BC

(Editor’s note: Mainstream Canada is a fish farm company.)

Just Posted

Music that celebrates the Skeena landscape premieres in Terrace

“Skeena Suite” was dedicated to and conducted by retiring music teacher Geoff Parr

ValhallaFest readies for second annual weekend event

Number of festival-goers expected to double

Family frustrated Terrace dad with advanced cancer must wait weeks for treatment

‘We can see his health declining every day,’ daughter says

Board of Education hires independent consultant to review SD82 reassignments

Review will not change recent decisions but will gather input, says board chair

VIDEO: B.C. First Nation plans to launch legal challenge after Trans Mountain approval

Meanwhile, Premier John Horgan says he’ll continue to defend the B.C. coast

Life’s work of talented B.C. sculptor leads to leukemia

Former Salmon Arm resident warns of dangers of chemical contact

Billboard posted along B.C.’s Highway of Tears to remember missing and murdered Indigenous women

Billboards featuring Indigenous artwork to be placed in Surrey, Kamloops and near Prince George

Federal cabinet ministers visit Edmonton, Calgary, in wake of TMX approval

Natural Resources Minister Amarjeet Sohi is set to visit Trans Mountain Corp.’s terminal in Edmonton

B.C. municipality prepares to forbid overnight camping by homeless despite court ruling

While courts have ruled against blanket bans, Langley City is employing a site-by-site approach

B.C. auditor says Indigenous grad rate highest ever but education gaps exist

The percentage of Indigenous students graduating from B.C. public high schools has hit its highest level ever

Statistics Canada reports annual pace of inflation rises in May to 2.4%

Transportation prices gained 3.1 per cent as the cost of air transportation added 8.9 per cent

MPs hear retired B.C. nurse’s petition to change compensation for fatal medical errors

Teri McGrath wants provinces to implement no-fault system for medical errors

Demonstrators on either side of Trans Mountain debate clash in Vancouver

Crowd heard from member of Indigenous-led coalition that hopes to buy 51% of expansion project

Most Read