Nice try, but refinery proposal just won’t work

Andre Carrel is a retired public sector administrator living in Terrace, B.C.

I spoke against the Northern Gateway Project in my oral presentation to the Joint Review Panel in May. I have not changed my mind on the project’s merits, but I feel compelled to speak up in support of Enbridge.

Their project raises valid questions about the risks associated with the operation of a pipeline through British Columbia’s rugged northwest super tanker traffic in Douglas Channel.

Enbridge may have embellished some aspects of the project, its impact on local employment, for example, in an effort to gain public support.

But concerning the economics of the proposal, especially from the perspective of corporate gain, Enbridge knows what it is talking about.

Enbridge is a pipeline company. The company’s expertise is in making a profit from building and operating oil pipelines.

Yes, oil has spilled from the company’s pipelines, disastrously so in some instances. The US National Transportation Safety Board labelled Enbridge’s response to one spill as a Keystone Kops operation.

They may have been harsh, but it would be banal to write off the rash of Enbridge spills on the grounds that “accidents will happen,” although accidents do indeed happen in every industry.

Safety training, inspections, and investment in the global scheduled airline industry are extensive and yet, that industry has chalked up fourteen fatal crashes in the past twelve months, killing 498 crew and passengers.

Accidents in any industry do and will continue to happen.

But the subject here is not the pipeline; it is the proposal by a wealthy media personality to build a $13-billion refinery in Kitimat.

This proposal offered two trump cards: massive new employment in the region, and the elimination of bitumen carrying super tankers in Douglas Channel. I had to check my calendar: is it April 1 already?

This refinery proposal falls into the well-meaning but utterly useless “why doesn’t somebody …” category of announcements. Let me compare this refinery announcement with the Northern Gateway pipeline announcement.

Bitumen producers in Alberta were looking for markets, and refiners in Asia (not only China) were looking for crude. In the presence of a secure supply and a strong demand, connecting the two would seem to be child’s play.

Not so fast. If a Northern Gateway pipeline is eventually approved, and that is still a long way from being a certainty, it will have taken a major international pipeline company over a decade to move the project from initial proposal to final approval.

And that’s with an experienced proponent in the pipeline industry.

So what are we to make of the refinery proponent’s announcement?

Let us assume that the refinery gets rapid approval, that it does not run into financing difficulties, that contracts with product vendors and customers are signed, and that the plant is designed and built in record time.

How would a refinery in Kitimat prevent the sale of raw bitumen to any customer in the pacific region?

With the pipeline in place, with Kitimat harbour having the capacity to handle super tankers, and with Douglas Channel navigational aides for such traffic in place, how difficult would it be to get approval for bitumen-carrying super tankers to get permission to enter the channel?

How much time would be needed, and how many hurdles would have to be overcome for the design, engineering, permitting, financing, and construction of a refinery in Kitimat. A decade? Maybe longer?

What about the Northern Gateway pipeline project in the meantime? Should Enbridge be told to shelve that project until the refinery project is guaranteed?

The refinery proposal is a Northern Gateway project distraction. A more likely job-creating economic booster for this region would be to wait for the owners of the Vancouver Canucks to build a plywood plant in Terrace so as to put a halt to raw log exports.

Andre Carrel is a retired public sector administrator living in Terrace, B.C.

Just Posted

Snowfall warning issued for Hwy 16 – Smithers to Terrace

Cloudy, warmer rain showers are expected to change to snow after midnight.

Ministry defends proposed hunting restrictions

Options intended to balance population and allocation to move forward with input by April or May

Terrace RCMP Inspector Syd Lecky transferring to Kamloops

Departure likely months away, replacement process yet to begin

Province to boost ER services at Mills Memorial

Money to add salaried doctor positions

Province opens public input on policing standards

The move flows from recommendations of the Missing Women Commission of Inquiry

Vancouver Aquarium’s resident octopus released into ocean

Staff let the Giant Pacific octopus go into the waters near Bowen Island so she can reproduce

How to keep local news visible in your Facebook feed

Facebook has changed the news feed to emphasize personal connections. You might see less news.

Where Canadians buy real estate abroad: report

Hot Spots: Top 30 home-buying destinations for Canadians in the Americas

Ban on grizzly bear hunt, new rules take effect April 1

Taxidermists, tanners will have to report on any grizzly bears or parts brought to them

Ontario father grief stricken over murder of ex-wife and children

‘No words to explain,’ grieving father of slain teens says in statement

Russian Embassy calls Trudeau’s criticism of Putin unproductive

The Russian Embassy is firing back at Trudeau for criticizing President Vladimir Putin

Murder charge upgraded for man accused in Toronto gay village death

Man accused the death of a woman in the Toronto gay village had charge upgraded after new evidence

Former NHL player Theo Fleury visits B.C. First Nations community

Abuse survivor Theo Fleury has been working with communities focusing on healing since 2009 and visited Esketemc First Nation in the Cariboo this week.

City to lobby province after councillor accused of crime refused to resign

Dave Murray was sentenced to nine months for a sexual assault that occurred 26 years ago

Most Read