Is charitable giving unethical?

Is charitable giving unethical?

One of the ongoing long-term puzzles in human society is how best to behave ethically, to practice virtue in our human relationships, especially when dealing with strangers. Few of us are very good at it, but in a complex and hazardous world with varied cultural expectations, it’s important to try.

The ongoing Federal Government scandal to do with SNC Lavalin’s bribery of foreign officials (illegal under Canadian law) illustrates this truism quite well. Bribery may be standard operating procedure in some foreign countries, and failure to bribe to obtain contracts may very well mean failure, period. Thus, it’s not surprising that when a company is operating abroad it might apply a kind of, “When in Rome…” philosophy.

Recently, students enrolled in a business ethics class at UNBC held an Oxford-style debate on the ethics of charity. The proposition argued was that, “Charity is unethical.” Leaving aside the oddball, counterintuitive and unbalanced nature of this proposition, it was refreshing to encounter this kind of academic exercise in our local institutions, particularly in a business course, a field in which profit, not charity, is generally exalted as the measure of all virtue.

But along from their concern for profit, businesses frequently donate large sums of money to individuals and communities. There are tax write-offs and good PR associated with such generosity, but these gifts provide real benefits to the receivers.

Most religions promote kindness as virtue. In the West, charity has always been a pillar of Christian doctrine. Giving is one of the ​Perfections (paramitas) of Buddhism (but to be “perfect” it must be selfless, without expectation of reward or praise). In Islam Mohammed reportedly asserted that “Charity…quiets the wrath of God and takes away one’s sin as the water puts out the fire.” Similar inclinations or directions can be found in most religious texts.

Religious beliefs provide a metaphysical justification for generosity. God says it’s good, so do it. It is arguable, however, that generosity is a good in and of itself, that is, that god or no god, charity is a desirable thing for both giver and recipient. Under either assumption, there’s a strangeness in the proposition at issue, a paradoxical claim that might as well have stated, “White is black.”

The affirmative team (who lost) tried a kind of end run on the proposition. They conceded that helping the needy and doing things that are beneficial to society as a whole are admirable actions, but argued that such charity is unethical because it is self-defeating and inefficient. This fact is evident, they argued, in that personal charity is often provided to make the giver feel good, not necessarily to address real needs. Further, most major charities have large, salaried staffs that consume donations that could be used more beneficially. Thus, they argued, charity should be operated by government at the lowest possible cost, with transparent procedures that ensure fair and effective address of needs.

The negative team (who won), successfully argued that generosity is a social duty, beneficial to both givers and receivers.

Regardless of charity’s source, most recipients that are suffering and without help probably don’t care a fig where their relief comes from, although they may be suitably grateful once their needs are met. But how best to meet those needs remains problematic for society in general, and a challenge worth discussing.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

The Nisga’a Valley Health Authority reported an isolated cluster of COVID-19 cases among non-direct care staff at the New Aiyansh Health Centre. (Gary Fiegehen/Nisga’a Lisims Government)
New Aiyansh Health Centre experiencing COVID-19 cluster among non-direct care staff

Nisga’a Valley Health Authority asking residents to cancel appointments outside the Nass Valley

A photo of the CervixCheck at-home test kit, developed by Eve Medical. (Submitted Photo/Katina Pollard, Métis Nation British Columbia)
Pilot project puts cancer screening into the hands of northwest B.C. women

Métis women experience barriers to cervical cancer screening

Brett Alexander Jones is wanted on several warrants province-wide, in connection with multiple charges. Jan. 21, 2021. Kitimat RCMP photo
Kitimat RCMP searching for man wanted on several warrants province-wide

Jones is described as a five-foot 10-inches Caucasian man, with blond hair and blue eyes.

The Nisga’a Lisims Government has extended its state of local emergency. (File photo)
Nisga’a state of local emergency extended, vaccines delayed

There are 21 active COVID-19 cases in the Nisga’a Valley Health Authority

Businesses continue to struggle under COVID-19 restrictions as the pandemic reaches the one-year mark. (B.C. government)
Another 564 COVID-19 cases, mass vaccine plan coming Friday

15 more deaths, community cluster declared in Williams Lake

A specialized RCMP team is investigating a suspicious trailer, which might have connections to the illicit drug trade, found abandoned outside a Cache Creek motel. (Photo credit: <em>Journal</em> files)
Police probe U-Haul trailer linked to illicit drugs left outside Cache Creek motel

Hazardous materials found inside believed to be consistent with the production of illicit drugs

Premier John Horgan leaves the podium following his first press conference of the year as he comments on various questions from the media in the Press Gallery at B.C. Legislature in Victoria, B.C., on Monday, January 13, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Chad Hipolito
Interprovincial travel restrictions a no-go, Horgan says after reviewing legal options

The B.C. NDP government sought legal advice as concerns of travel continue

Gem Lake Top, at Big White Ski Resort, seen at Jan. 8. (Big White Ski Resort)
Big White cancels $7.3M in lift tickets, accommodations due to COVID-19 orders

Since November, the ski resort has been forced to make several changes

Darlene Curylo scratched a $3M ticket, BCLC’s largest ever scratch and win prize. (BCLC)
Kelowna woman in shock after winning BCLC’s largest-ever instant-ticket prize

Darlene Curylo couldn’t believe her eyes when she saw the amount of money she’d won from a scratch ticket

While each person has different reasons for becoming homeless, a UBCO study shows they learn through their interactions with different services to perform ‘as homeless’ based on the expectations of service providers. (Contributed)
Kelowna homeless forced to ‘perform’ for resources, says UBCO study

One participant in the study said ‘It is about looking homeless, but not too homeless’

Gov. Gen. Julie Payette takes the royal salute from the Guard of Honour as she makes her way deliver the the throne speech, Wednesday, September 23, 2020 in Ottawa. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Fred Chartrand
Gov. Gen. Julie Payette resigns, apologizes for ‘tensions’ at Rideau Hall

Payette, who is the Queen’s representative in Canada, has been the governor general since 2017

Grounded WestJet Boeing 737 Max aircraft are shown at the airline’s facilities in Calgary, Alta., Tuesday, May 7, 2019. WestJet will operate the first commercial Boeing 737 Max flight in Canada today since the aircraft was grounded in 2019 following two deadly crashes. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jeff McIntosh
Passengers unfazed as WestJet returns Boeing 737 Max to service on Vancouver flight

After a lengthy review process, Transport Canada cleared the plane to return to Canadian airspace

The top part of the fossil burrow, seen from the side, with feathery lines from the disturbance of the soil – thought to be caused by the worm pulling prey into the burrow. (Paleoenvironntal Sediment Laboratory/National Taiwan University)
PHOTOS: SFU researchers find evidence of ‘giant’ predatory worms on ocean floor

Fossils found the prove the existence of an ancient Taiwanese worm as long as two metres

Most Read