Health care under attack from within

“A universal health system is essential if you want a country that’s healthy and productive."

Neo-conservative economists have stressed “living within our means,” being “economically responsible,” and generally just lowering public expectations of what governments can or should do.

(I stress the word “general” here, because the hundreds of corporate lobbyists that visit government offices consistently deliver sitting MPs advice on what government can and should do for them. Usually these requests have little or nothing to do with general welfare but plenty to do with greasing the wheels of corporate activities.)

Given the high profile nature of health care among Canadians, as well as the lucrative market in delivering health care goods and services, it’s little wonder that corporations of all kinds from manufacturers of medical technology to drug companies and insurance providers are drooling to get a greater slice of the pie.

When universal public medical insurance was instituted through the Canada Health Act, some of these markets became strictly regulated. Most user fees for physicians’ services are prohibited under the act. Insurance is provided by a single government agency in each of the provinces and, until now, was guaranteed to a national standard. This government single-payer plan creates tremendous cost efficiencies.

Compared to the bewildering system of health insurance in the US, Canadians receive on average far better care at less cost.

Harper’s Conservatives, however, prefer a “free-market” solution to all problems, and although they don’t wish to alienate Canadian voters too dreadfully by attacking the Canada Health Act directly, they have taken strategies from US Republicans.

A most effective Republican strategy to make a government program dysfunctional is to starve it for revenue. This strategy exists in all the Republican-governed US states, in their Congress, in Canadian provinces that have conservative-leaning governments (such as BC), and in our federal government itself. The ongoing tax cuts, especially corporate tax cuts, that have characterized Canadian legislation under the Conservatives have effectively removed hundreds of billions of dollars in revenue from government programs over the past decade and a half.

Corporate media trumpet, as if it were holy writ, the “news” of government mismanagement and of the “inefficiency” of public services. This public sector bashing and corporate self-flattery condition Canadian citizens simply to expect less from government, precisely what Harper plans to do.

Recently Harper’s finance minister delivered an ultimatum about capping health spending. As always, the sotto voce muttering in the background from the Fraser Institute promotes “experimenting” with other health delivery systems, a euphemism for various privatization schemes.

There is another view, however, one quite eloquently argued by a group called the Canadian Health Coalition ( Their Nov. 2011 report soundly debunks the air of crisis frequently to be found in mainstream media coverage.

Harvard economist Robert G. Evans states unequivocally that the argument that public health care is “fiscally unsustainable” is “a lie.” Population growth and inflation, not the aging population, cause most of the growth in health spending. Further, “medicare spending takes up roughly the same share of tax revenues as it did 20 years ago.”

The highest rises in total health care spending are in precisely the areas not covered by our single-payer plan (e.g. prescription drugs, dental care, home care). If these were covered by a single-payer system health care spending would be much more efficient.

The editor-in-chief of the New England Journal of Medicine argues cogently that in contrast to our system, for-profit health care is expensive, inefficient and inequitable, precisely the problems that the Canada Health Act skillfully, if imperfectly, manages.

CIBC Scholar-in-Residence André Picard states, “A universal health system is essential if you want a country that’s healthy and productive on many levels; it’s an economic driver and it’s a tool for social justice.”

To Harper, “living within our means” means shrinking corporate taxes, creating artificial deficits, generating artificial panic, and, if we let him, gradually replacing Canada’s fair public health insurance system with an increasingly unequal private one.


Al Lehmann is a teacher living in Terrace, BC.



Just Posted

Volunteers step up to the grill to help the Ksan Society

A group of volunteers from the Northwest Community College are flipping burgers, walking to help after this year’s Coldest Night of the Year fundraiser was cancelled.

Greyhound cleared to end routes in northern B.C., Vancouver Island

Company says nine routes have dropped 30% in ridership in last five years

UPDATE: Air quality advisory ended for Terrace

People with chronic underlying medical conditions should postpone strenuous exercise until the advisory is lifted.

Mills Memorial Hospital financing formula released

Regional taxpayers to pay $113.7 million for new facility.

Greyhound cleared to end routes in northern B.C., Vancouver Island

Company says nine routes have dropped 30% in ridership in last five years

Therapy dogs make appearance at B.C. Games

The St. John’s Ambulance therapy dog program launches a pilot project at the 2018 Kamloops B.C. Winter Games

How to keep local news visible in your Facebook feed

Facebook has changed the news feed to emphasize personal connections. You might see less news.

Federal budget to unveil incentive for 5-week second parent leave: official

Goal behind the measure is to give parents more incentive to share child-rearing responsibilities

Notley says Alberta watching B.C. court bid closely, will get no free ride on it

Alberta Premier Rachel Notley ended the three-week ban on B.C. wine, calming the trade war

Trudeau ends troubled India trip in his comfort zone of hockey and youth

The players, 18-25, came to New Delhi from Ladakhi in northern India, as part of outreach program

OLYMPIC ROUNDUP: Kim Boutin named Canada’s flag bearer for closing ceremony

Two more medals for Canada, including the bronze in men’s hockey

Team Canada’s Dave Duncan apologizes after drunken joyride in Pyeongchang

Duncan, his wife Maja and Canadian technical coach William Raine detained by South Korean police

Czechmate: Canada wins men’s Olympic hockey bronze

Vernon’s Andrew Ebbett scores twice as Canada beats Czech Republic 6-4

Canucks fold 5-3 in first ever trip to Vegas

Daniel Sedin had two points as Canucks fall to the Golden Knights Friday night

Most Read