Government stifles opposition

SINCE FIRST elected an MP 50 years ago former prime minister John Napier Turner has fumed over parliamentary abuses.

SINCE FIRST elected an MP 50 years ago former prime minister John Napier Turner has fumed over parliamentary abuses. Yet those abuses grow and we voters accept them.

Turner was speaking  May 3  at the 25th Annual Public Policy Forum Testimonial Dinner honouring the six living former prime ministers. Chretien was absent;  the other five each gave a 15-minute talk.

Turner listed a number of faults with how parliament works today.

First, the government presents far too many omnibus bills. Bills that should deal only with one topic instead include everything but the kitchen sink. For instance, a  budget  bill introduced recently, which in the old days dealt only with finance, repeals the Kyoto Protocol Implementation Act and outlines major changes to the environmental assessment process, gives cabinet authority over resource projects,   changes the Fisheries Act to apply only to major waterways, and lumps in immigration.

Turner argues a budget bill should deal only with budget, not bundle in every pet project dear to the heart of the prime minister. How can MPs intelligently  discuss or vote for a bill that includes so many varying subjects? Suppose you support one, but not the others? Currently Ottawa is facing an omnibus finance bill which the NDP would like divided into at least five separate bills.

Gone are the rousing debates when Diefenbaker would stand in the House of Commons, arguing extemporaneously, jowls jiggling. Debates had drama and import. Turner says no one watches parliamentary debates or reads Hansard any more. Little wonder we are less engaged with the daily doings in parliament. There are no debates worth watching.  Often the camera fixes on a lone MP backed by an empty chamber echoing like an unused warehouse.

The modern parliament performs for TV cameras during question period, Turner says,  each MP jostling for the best camera angle and sound bite.

Both Turner and Kim Campbell decry the impotence of government backbenchers who are whipped into voting the government line even on matters where the government has no definite position staked out. Voting in favour of the government’s position is legitimate, Campbell says, but she sees no reason why MPs aren’t allowed to vote to suit their constituents on  matters less crucial to the government.

Turner says 50 years ago the elected MP had sole authority over his constituency and what his voters wanted. Now, MPs can’t vote independently on these smaller or more local issues. They are expected to toe the government line regardless of whether or not the MP is living up to the personal platform that got him elected.

Turner says far too much authority rests with the prime minister’s office. MPs are largely irrelevant. Campbell remembers dissenters could speak up only in caucus; outside of caucus they had to zip their lips and publicly support the government regardless

Victoria’s Liberal government has adopted Ottawa’s ways with gusto.  Besides curtailing debate, with only 11 days remaining before the B.C. legislature rises for the summer, Clark’s government has introduced 14 pieces of legislation, including the bill to return to the PST. This single bill took four months to draft and contains over 40 clauses, each deserving of individual and unlimited discussion by all 83 MLAs.

One Victoria legislative reporter explained it is only through discussion by elected members before the bill is passed into law that we can know the intent of the law. Should the bill be at the heart of a future lawsuit, the court would be at a loss to know the legislators’ intention.

If only Turner had the power to revise Ottawa’s behaviour.

Just Posted

B.C. freestyle skier wins gold

Cassie Sharpe of Comox shines in the halfpipe

Annual Heritage Day celebration highlights Terrace history, culture

Over 30 vendors displayed various vintage and historic items from the city’s past on Feb.17 in the Sportsplex Banquet Room.

Terrace River Kings win playoffs

Defeating Williams Lake Stampeders, the team now heads to the Coy Cup for the fourth year in a row

First annual Valentines Day Memorial Walk to honor missing and murdered Indigenous people held in Terrace

Mayor Carol Leclerc and RCMP Cst. Angela Rabut joined members of the Radek family and walkers on Feb. 14 from the Chill Soda Shop on Highway 16 to the Tempo Gas Station.

Most Highway 16 closures for avalanches in years after multiple dumps of snow

Highway 16 has had four closures between Terrace and Prince Rupert due to 35 mile avalanche area

How to keep local news visible in your Facebook feed

Facebook has changed the news feed to emphasize personal connections. You might see less news.

Virtue and Moir end ice dance careers with Olympic gold

Virtue and Moir’s gold medal win at the Olympics makes them the world’s most decorated figure skaters

Canadians find living in small spaces teaches creativity

Canadian families choosing to live in small spaces to bring closeness to children

SAR suspends search for missing man at Sun Peaks

RCMP will continue to search for a missing man near Kamloops but SAR has suspended their role

Lottery will help save children’s lives

Each ticket gets you a chance to win a lot of money, while helping a lot of kids

B.C. RCMP officer officially cleared in car wash shooting incident

A report found the Salmon Arm officer fired 14 bullets at the man’s truck

Interest in Canadian Armed Forces remains high

Canada seeks about 5,000 recruits each year for its regular forces of about 68,000

Rules reviewed to keep drug money out of B.C. real estate

Investigator looking at loans as well as casinos, David Eby says

Most Read