Panel’s recommendation on Northern Gateway ‘not surprising’, say environmental groups

And Enbridge says the report is an important step toward construction

  • Dec. 19, 2013 1:00 p.m.

Reaction to the news that the federal environmental panel has recommended the approval of the proposed Enbridge Northern Gateway pipeline is coming in, with environmental groups saying the recommendation is not surprising.

“It’s exactly as we suspected. The Joint Review Panel failed to take into account the views of the people of B.C. who feel this project isn’t acceptable,” said Greg Knox of SkeenaWild, a northwestern B.C. environmental group, on the panel’s overall recommendation that the federal government approve the 1,177-km twin pipeline system and marine terminal, which as proposed would transport Alberta oilsands crude to the port at Kitimat.

Knox is, however, surprised the panel can determine that the chance of environmental effects are very low.

“You can’t clean up oil,” said Knox of the potential of a marine spill. “It’s impossible.”

And references to a world class response to a spill are wrong as well, he said.

“The most successful response is to clean up 5 – 15 per cent of the oil. And that’s under really good conditions,” said Knox.

He’s now calling upon the provincial government to follow through on its commitment to oppose the Gateway project.

“This was the easiest approval hurdle for Enbridge,” said Knox of the panel report. “What they don’t have is First Nations approval or the public’s approval.”

He also said there’s a chance of mass civil disobedience should the federal cabinet follow along with the panel’s report.

And Knox is predicting the federal Conservative government will lose the B.C. seats it needs to keep its majority in the next federal election.

Environmental group Sierra Club BC criticized the National Energy Board joint review panel process, which saw public hearings in 21 cities in British Columbia and Alberta over an 18 month period beginning in January, 2012.

“The panel’s recommendation is a disappointment, but unsurprising given such a flawed process,” said Sierra Club BC campaigns director Caitlyn Vernon. “At all turns, the federal government  undermined the credibility of the process as they changed the rules, dismissed any consideration of global warming impacts, unlawfully delayed critical information on endangered humpback whales, and – the day before the hearings began – announced support for the project while name-calling the concerned citizens who spoke up against it.”

In the panel’s report, they acknowledge that certain concerns from the public did not fall under the panel’s mandate.

“These issues included both ‘upstream’ oil development effects and ‘downstream’ refining and use of the products shipped on the pipelines and tankers,” reads the report, which also notes the consideration of ‘downstream’ emissions that could occur from upgrading, refining, and diluted bitumen use in China and elsewhere was outside of the panel’s mandate. Trade policy, renewable energy, and industrial strategy were also beyond the panel’s scope. The panel “did consider emissions arising from construction activities, pipeline operations, and the engines of tankers in Canadian territorial waters.”

And in a release, Enbridge’s Northern Gateway Project said they are reviewing the findings.

“From the beginning of this project, Northern Gateway has worked with one goal in mind: to access new markets by building a safer, better pipeline,” said Janet Holder, leader of the Northern Gateway Project. “The Joint Review Panel conducted the most comprehensive and science-based pipeline review in Canadian history and their report reflects the input of thousands of Canadians. Their report is an important step towards that goal.”

Federal Natural Resources Minister Joe Oliver issued a release stating that, “no energy project will be approved unless it is safe for Canadians and safe for the environment.” The federal cabinet must make a final decision on federal permits for the project by July 2014.

“Now that we have received the report, we will thoroughly review it, consult with affected Aboriginal groups and then make our decision,” he said.


Just Posted

Former resident wins filmmaking award

Veronika Kurz will be able to make her film with $15,000 cash and in-kind services, up to $100,000

Terrace River Kings win CIHL regular season

The boys held a strong enough lead in points to claim the banner after a 15-2 win Saturday

Terrace residents discuss poverty at provincial engagement meeting

80 people were there as well as the Minister of Social Development and Poverty Reduction

Shames Mountain named one of the world’s Top 10 ski resorts

The UK magazine listed Shames alongside Whistler and hills in Italy, Japan and Austria

Who wants to live here?

Northwest governments partner on marketing plan to attract workforce, residents

Senior randomly stabbed in B.C. mall food court

Woman arrested after victim, 71, suffers serious injuries

B.C. Liberal hopefuls begin final leadership push

Five MLAs, one outsider pitch policies to party members

Vancouver Island marijuana producer bought by Aphria in $230M deal

Aphria’s annual production forecast increases to 230,000 kgs

UPDATED: ‘Young, innocent’ teen hit during Vancouver shootout dies

15-year-old Coquitlam boy was in a car driving by the scene

Ontario man charged with selling Canadian’s usernames and passwords

Ontario man ran site that peddled billions of pieces of personal data: RCMP

Video: B.C. documentary features Okanagan ice climbing

First documentary for Penticton filmmaker captures elusive Okanagan ice climbing

David Emerson quits lumber talks as legal action begins

Former federal minister served as B.C. softwood trade point man

Singer of the Cranberries dead at 46

Her publicist says Dolores O’Riordan died suddenly Monday in London. The cause of death wasn’t immediately available.

Most Read