Feds leave First Nations in limbo

Kitsumkalum and Kitselas have been waiting for months on treaty deal

  • Jul. 11, 2012 4:00 p.m.

THE FEDERAL government is acting in bad faith by leaving two local First Nations in land claims limbo, says the head of the BC Treaty Commission.

Both the Kitsumkalum and Kitselas have been waiting for months for the federal government to formally introduce land and cash components of what will form crucial pieces of a tentative agreement in principle for each, says chief commissioner Sophie Pierre.

But with summer now here and Parliament finished until the fall, there’s no way of knowing when those components might be presented, she says.

“What we have kept on saying is that negotiations need to be done in good faith,” said Pierre. “We had all expected this spring to have items in place [leading toward consideration of agreements in principle].”

“And now it’s incredibly frustrating that the federal government continues to have this appearance that it is committed to good faith negotiations. We keep saying we do not see evidence of good faith negotiations,” said Pierre.

The Kitsumkalum and the Kitselas have been negotiating with the federal and provincial governments since 1997 to agree upon treaties establishing a land base for each, cash, self-government powers and jurisdiction over natural resources.

Negotiators for all parties reached what would be tentative agreements in principle this spring but progress has been stalled since then because the federal government has yet to approve the land and cash components agreed to at the bargaining table.

The BC Treaty Commission is an independent body which oversees the steps taken toward final treaty settlement.

While federal and provincial cabinets must sign off on agreements in principle, the terms are subject to a vote by the entire  membership of the affected First Nation.

Agreements in principle, once agreed to by all concerned, form the basis for final treaty negotiations and it is rare that final treaties differ from an agreement in principle.

Pierre said the treaty commission knows of no outstanding reason why the federal government cannot follow through on a tentative agreement in principle.

“These are treaties we consider very doable and there are no outstanding challenges. If they can’t do it for these treaties, what can we expect where there are real challenges,” Pierre added.

And since there are no time limits that parties need to respect, there is no accountability, she said.

“What that means is that the other parties are left holding the bag,” Pierre continued.

“Where does that leave the First Nation when one of the parties isn’t coming through?”

Making matters worse for First Nations is that they borrow from governments against eventual treaty cash settlements to provide the money to negotiate, she said.

“So for the past year these First Nations have been borrowing money to keep negotiating when there is a land and cash offer they’ve been waiting to hear about,” said Pierre.

She said the First Nations should not repay what they have borrowed over the past year because of the federal government delay in approving a tentative agreement in principle.


Just Posted

Snowfall warning issued for Hwy 16 – Smithers to Terrace

Cloudy, warmer rain showers are expected to change to snow after midnight.

Ministry defends proposed hunting restrictions

Options intended to balance population and allocation to move forward with input by April or May

Terrace RCMP Inspector Syd Lecky transferring to Kamloops

Departure likely months away, replacement process yet to begin

Province to boost ER services at Mills Memorial

Money to add salaried doctor positions

Province opens public input on policing standards

The move flows from recommendations of the Missing Women Commission of Inquiry

Vancouver Aquarium’s resident octopus released into ocean

Staff let the Giant Pacific octopus go into the waters near Bowen Island so she can reproduce

How to keep local news visible in your Facebook feed

Facebook has changed the news feed to emphasize personal connections. You might see less news.

Murder charge upgraded for man accused in Toronto gay village death

Man accused the death of a woman in the Toronto gay village had charge upgraded after new evidence

Former NHL player Theo Fleury visits B.C. First Nations community

Abuse survivor Theo Fleury has been working with communities focusing on healing since 2009 and visited Esketemc First Nation in the Cariboo this week.

A B.C. council takes action in wake of former municipal politician’s sentencing

Dave Murray was sentenced to nine months for a sexual assault that occurred 26 years ago.

Harsher fines, new off-road vehicle rules in effect to combat B.C. wildfires

Anyone who starts a wildfire could be ordered to pay up to $1,000,000

Muddy water found in taps at B.C. hospital prompts investigation

Northern Health to hire consultant to examine three facilities for potential contamination

RCMP officer charged after pedestrian struck at crosswalk

A man suffered a broken leg and head lacerations after being struck by the police vehicle in 2017

B.C. NDP offers tax breaks to jumpstart LNG Canada in Kitimat

‘We’re not giving away more money,’ Premier John Horgan says

Most Read