Dog owner drops attempt at compensation

Thornhill, BC man had successfully stopped his dog from being destroyed

A THORNHILL resident who successfully went to court and saved his dog from being destroyed has now dropped an attempt to be compensated for his costs.

Paul MacNeil had started a court action for compensation against the Kitimat-Stikine regional district, which had wanted his dog destroyed, but abandoned the effort shortly before a hearing was to be held Jan. 20.

“The bottom line is we didn’t have a case,” said MacNeil Jan. 21. “It would’ve cost another $30,000. I can’t afford that.”

He says he should have asked for compensation at the time of the first court proceedings.

MacNeil’s decision came after speaking with his lawyer and with his mother who has worked in the legal profession for 40 years.

In April 2012, police seized MacNeil’s German shepherd Cane from MacNeil’s Thornhill home after receiving a call that he had bit a child.

Cane was first placed in the Terrace shelter as the regional district’s Thornhill Animal Shelter wasn’t open and later moved to the Thornhill shelter.

The regional district applied to the court for an order of destruction for the dog.

It took nearly a year for the destruction order attempt to get to trial, culminating Feb. 28, 2013 when, after two days of testimony, the judge determined that none of the conditions to declare the dog dangerous had been satisfied.

On Sept. 26, 2013 MacNeil filed a notice of claim to recover some of his legal costs, naming the regional district and several of its employees in seeking $25,000 spent in successfully preventing the regional district from obtaining the order to destroy Cane.

The action against the regional district also alleged that regional district administrator Bob Marcellin said MacNeil was entitled to compensation but there was no followup and a promised written report on the whole matter was never provided.

The regional district reply, filed Oct. 24, 2013, said Marcellin denied making any offer or promise of financial compensation for the handling of MacNeil’s dog, but Marcellin did admit to asking MacNeil how the regional district might make amends for the sedation of Cane on that day.

The planned Jan. 20 hearing was for a settlement conference, session to determine if the two sides could come to an agreement or if that wasn’t possible, to prepare their cases for trial.

Marcellin said he was glad the suit had been dropped.

“The whole situation has been unfortunate and has been hard on all parties involved,” he said. “I’m glad it is over.”

Marcellin said he apologized on behalf of the regional district to MacNeil for what had happened.

“Some things were unfortunate on our part,” he said.

“Some things we shouldn’t have done,” Marcellin added, saying he was referring to the “drugging of the dog.”

Marcellin didn’t want to comment on whether any discipline or reprimands were directed toward regional district staff involved or what that discipline may have been.








Just Posted

Terrace SAR aims high for new headquarters

A huge financial grant will enable Terrace Search and Rescue to move… Continue reading

New Terrace squash court opens at Summit Square Apartments

For the first time in years, squash players will be able to play on weekends in Terrace

UPDATE: Tsunami warning cancelled for coastal British Columbia

Warning issued following 7.9 earthquake off Kodiak, AK

Police encourage reporting of suspicious events following reports involving children

Terrace RCMP are asking the public to report any suspicious adult interactions… Continue reading

Soup kitchen sees “groundswell of community support”

Donations toward looming tax bill push non-profit back in the black

Tsunami warnings 101: Canada

Here are some things to know about tsunami alerts in Canada and how they work

Castlegar homicide victim identified

The victim was 38-year-old Jordan Workman of Castlegar, B.C.

B.C. Liberal leadership candidates get one last prime-time pitch

Leadership campaign to be decided in Feb. 3 vote

Andrew Scheer on trade, Trump and Trudeau

Canada’s Conservative leader begins three-day visit to B.C.

Victims restrained, sex toys and cash stolen from B.C. adult store

Armed suspects sought in adult store robbery

Vancouver Islanders ponder need for tsunami siren song

Alarm sounds in Port Alberni but not at the DND base in Esquimalt

Babcock, Goyette and Smyth honoured at Order of Hockey in Canada

Mike Babcock, from Saskatoon, guided the Detroit Red Wings to a Stanley Cup in 2008

Bell Canada alert prompts RCMP, privacy watchdog to probe data breach

Company spokesman: ‘Fewer than 100,000 customers were affected’

‘The tsunami alarm failed my household’: North Coast residents concerned over sirens, alerts

People living in northern communities share how they learned about Tuesday’s tsunami warning

Most Read