91-year-old Thornhill man loses court fight with RCMP

Larry Sommerfield sued the ministry of justice in small claims court, claiming they unduly destroyed his antique gun collection

Larry Sommerfield’s civil suit court date with the RCMP for destroying guns he owned did not go his way.

It’s true that there were many smoking guns following the fire at Larry Sommerfield’s Thornhill home in 2010. But when the 91-year-old man needed one, of the figurative kind, in his civil suit against the RCMP for destroying those guns, the judge simply didn’t find one.

“The RCMP acted in good faith,” said justice Terence Wright in his oral judgment which ruled in favour of the defence in Sommerfield’s small claims case against the B.C. ministry of justice, the official representative for the provincial RCMP, Monday, March 23 at the Terrace court house. He added that after the fire in March of 2010, the officers took the 10 charred and burnt guns into their possession to secure them, and in fact had a duty to do so as there was no reasonable way for them to determine at the time whether or not they were a risk to the public.

Months after the March 2010 fire, Sommerfield, representing himself and after filing a complaint with the Terrace RCMP directly, sued the ministry in small claims court.

He spent over four years researching and building his case, in which he claimed the RCMP officers unduly confiscated his guns and that when he signed a release giving his permission for the RCMP to destroy the guns he was under duress and misled. The case took up four court days and heard testimony from four witnesses. The judge’s decision came just over five years after the fire.

The case in part hinged on whether or not that release signed by Sommerfield at hospital after the fire where he was being treated for serious burns to his arm, giving the officers permission to destroy the guns, was valid. Wright ruled that Sommerfield voluntarily signed a release allowing the officers to destroy the guns, and was not intimidated and misled into signing the release as he maintained.

Wright said that Sommerfield’s memory of the signing and when it took place was simply mistaken and that corroborative evidence tended to be consistent with the defence’s version of events.

Wright said he was “in no way suggesting the claimant is not telling the truth as he recalled to the court … mistaken about events, nothing more.”

Wright said in his ruling that Sommerfield was lucid and rational in an audio recording recorded at the hospital after the fire, submitted as evidence by the defense at the encouragement of the judge, who wanted to hear it in order to determine Sommerfield’s mental state.

“There is no evidence the plaintiff didn’t have full intellectual capacity,” said Wright.

As the claimant failed to prove the defence was liable, any question of money owed to Sommerfield was not an issue, said Wright.

This was not welcome news for Sommerfield, who said the case shook his trust in the RCMP who he believes made an error and tried to cover it up.

He called the decision “a joke” after the ruling and said that “judges can also be mistaken.”

“I didn’t realize that much emphasis would be put on that I signed the release,” he added, but said he didn’t think hiring a lawyer would have helped his cause. Sommerfield maintained afterwards that the release he signed used the term “firearm” and that “a gun that cannot shoot is not a firearm” – a familiar refrain heard from Sommerfield in court.

Sommerfield said he wouldn’t be appealing the ruling.

“I’m not going to bother,” he said, “for the four or five thousand dollars it could get me. I’ve had enough of it.”

Still, he seemed surprised the judge didn’t decide in his favour.

“I was expecting at least something,” he said. “I get nothing, but I don’t need the money.”

Mostly, he just wants his story to be told so that others can learn from his experience, he said, adding that he is going to “make a file [on the case] and put it in the library for others.”

 

Just Posted

Festival of Mini-Trees raises almost $7,000 for Dr. R.E.M. Lee Hospital Foundation

Twenty Christmas trees decked out with merchandise, gift cards were given out in raffle draw

Caledonia Kermode basketball team holds first-ever Men’s Health Night fundraiser

Approximately $250 was raised during the senior boys’ home opener game

Here are the top earners at Coast Mountains School District

Audited financial report released for 2018/2019 fiscal year

Skeena Voices | The wild path

Courtenay Crucil is a nature-based therapist and herbalist who helps people with the earth in mind

Northwest B.C. physician receives Medal of Good Citizenship Award

Dr. Peter Newbery was one of 18 people in B.C. to get provincial recognition

VIDEO: SNL skewers Trudeau’s mockery of Trump in high school cafeteria sketch

The three world leaders won’t let Trump sit at the cool kids’ table

B.C. universities post $340 million worth of surpluses thanks to international student tuition

Students call for spending as international enrolment produces huge surpluses at many universities

Conservatives urge Morneau to deliver ‘urgent’ fall economic update

Morneau says the first thing the Liberals plan to do is bring in their promised tax cut for the middle class

INFOGRAPHIC: How much money did your local university or college make last year?

B.C. university and colleges posted a combined $340 million surplus in 2018/19

B.C. creates $8.5M organization to improve safety for health care workers

Group will bring together unions, province, health care organizations

Kovrig clings to humour as ‘two Michaels’ near one year in Chinese prison

Their detention is widely viewed as retaliation for Canada’s arrest of Chinese high-tech scion Meng Wanzhou

B.C. VIEWS: An engine that hums right along

First Nations are leading a new surge of investment in B.C.

Brain injury from domestic abuse a ‘public health crisis,’ says B.C. researcher

Nearly 80% of the domestic violence victims who reported to police last year were women

Most Read