This map comes from the PEW Research Center, a nonpartisan think tank based in Washington, DC, and shows how the Freedom House rates the electoral systems in the world.

Proportional representation but may only legitimize marginality

Dear Editor,

Electoral reform intends to better represent citizens. Proportional representation may but does not necessarily do that. A strict two-party system may also, and may do it better.

In defense of proportional representation and to correct Ellis Ross, there are examples of it that function acceptably, notably New Zealand, Netherlands, and Switzerland.

Equally, in defense of first-past-the-post, or a two-party system, and to correct Jennifer Rice, proportional representation is not necessary for broad representation, and it may even undermine it, depending on coalition weighting.

At its simplest, governance requires proposition and opposition to refine policy for legislation. Advanced political culture facilitates multiple representation within a rights environment of best practices. Multiple parties are not necessarily needed; two parties alone can also adopt best practices. Most important is an opposition, however it is formed.

A two-party system equally relies on coalition. Its advantage is greater familiarity with and inclusion of coalition members, who are also party members or who accept the party’s policy. Party constitution would necessarily welcome plurality to maximize the vote.

Proportional representation coalitions begin informally before elections and may hold during and after, but factionalism can compromise governance more than it does single-party governance with a single-party opposition.

The desire for proportional representation shows how diverse and unequal we both still are and are increasingly becoming. Defense of our rights environment proposes proportional representation but may only legitimize marginality.

The system that best addresses inequality and marginality also attempts to end them. Much work remains for that.

David Heinimann

Terrace, BC

Just Posted

Vopak expects 240 liquid gas-by-rail cars per day

North Coast residents can learn more about the Ridley Island-based project at the open houses

Bantam Kermodes defeat Seawolves in pre-season action

The Terrace bantam rep Kermodes won an exhibition game against Prince Rupert… Continue reading

CMTN unveils renovated House of Cedar

$18.4M upgrade and renovation cited as key to modern trades training

More than 35 B.C. mayors elected without contest

No other candidates for mayor in the upcoming local election in Prince Prince, Terrace, etc.

Mobile complaint team coming to B.C.’s northwest

Ombudsperson’s office wants to hear from wronged residents

Live bear cam: Let the fishing begin

Watch bears in Alaska’s Katmai National Park catch their dinner live.

Campaign seeks to add Farsi to B.C. school curriculum options

Group wants Farsi added to list of nine languages in policy covering second language requirements

Trudeau urges leaders to follow Nelson Mandela’s example at UN tribute

Peace summit in New York marks 100th birthday of former South African president

Senate seats filled in B.C., Saskatchewan

Canada’s newest senators are the first woman to lead the RCMP and a Cree Metis businessman

Newfoundland’s popular ‘merb’ys’ calendar is back

The calendar of burly, bearded mermen posing against scenic backdrops for charity returns

Cap rent increases at inflation rate, B.C. task force recommends

MLAs say drop annual increase that would allow 4.5% rise next year

School, church, old mining site make Heritage BC’s first ‘watch list’

The list includes sites in need of protection to maintain B.C.’s culture and history

Yowza! Twerk, emoji and facepalm are added to Scrabble dictionary, OK?

Merriam-Webster has announced 300 new words have been added to the spelling game

LGBTQ activists, allies in Victoria counter anti-SOGI protest with rally of their own

Lower Mainland activists plan to protest SOGI on legislature lawn, Sept. 29

Most Read