This map comes from the PEW Research Center, a nonpartisan think tank based in Washington, DC, and shows how the Freedom House rates the electoral systems in the world.

Proportional representation but may only legitimize marginality

Dear Editor,

Electoral reform intends to better represent citizens. Proportional representation may but does not necessarily do that. A strict two-party system may also, and may do it better.

In defense of proportional representation and to correct Ellis Ross, there are examples of it that function acceptably, notably New Zealand, Netherlands, and Switzerland.

Equally, in defense of first-past-the-post, or a two-party system, and to correct Jennifer Rice, proportional representation is not necessary for broad representation, and it may even undermine it, depending on coalition weighting.

At its simplest, governance requires proposition and opposition to refine policy for legislation. Advanced political culture facilitates multiple representation within a rights environment of best practices. Multiple parties are not necessarily needed; two parties alone can also adopt best practices. Most important is an opposition, however it is formed.

A two-party system equally relies on coalition. Its advantage is greater familiarity with and inclusion of coalition members, who are also party members or who accept the party’s policy. Party constitution would necessarily welcome plurality to maximize the vote.

Proportional representation coalitions begin informally before elections and may hold during and after, but factionalism can compromise governance more than it does single-party governance with a single-party opposition.

The desire for proportional representation shows how diverse and unequal we both still are and are increasingly becoming. Defense of our rights environment proposes proportional representation but may only legitimize marginality.

The system that best addresses inequality and marginality also attempts to end them. Much work remains for that.

David Heinimann

Terrace, BC

Just Posted

Terrace hockey player breaks all-time points record in Major Midget League

Prospects are bright for Mason Richey, suiting up this fall with the West Kelowna Warriors

UPDATE: Cullen demands better leadership over salmon crisis

MP urges ground-level cooperation amidst grim estimates of sockeye, chinook returns

Runners get festive in Terrace St. Patricks Day Run

Nearly all decked out in green, more than 160 people ran the first Terrace St Patty’s Day Run today

Junior Rage takes fifth in Super Series

The Terrace 16U girls won five and lost one game, making an impressive comeback in their final match

Terrace daycare at the centre of debate in B.C. Legislature

MLA for Chilliwack-Kent asked if new NDP health tax would apply to daycares like Willow Creek

REPLAY: B.C. this week in video

In case you missed it, here’s a look at replay-worthy highlights from across the province this week

How to keep local news visible in your Facebook feed

Facebook has changed the news feed to emphasize personal connections. You might see less news.

Suspect who attacked autistic man in Ontario could be from B.C.’s south coast: police

29-year-old man was sent to hospital with serious injuries

Privacy watchdog to explore Facebook leak

Canadian expert says his analytics company helped Trump campaign capitalize on private Facebook info

Woman struck and killed by self-driving Uber vehicle

Ride-hailing company suspends all road-testing of such vehicles in U.S. and Canada

Spring snow melt uncovers dirty needles in B.C. city

Vernon residents are upset with number of needles being found around town with spring melt

US would host majority of games at 2026 World Cup

A decision on the winning bid will be made June 13 at the FIFA Congress in Mexico

Most people in B.C. too ‘lazy,’ ‘apathetic’ to prepare for disasters: poll

Less than half of those surveyed aren’t insured for earthquakes and wildfires

Chris Hemsworth goes surfing in Tofino

The Australian actor donned a full body wetsuit to catch some waves on Vancouver Island this weekend

Most Read