Captain J.C. Bowen-Cothurst shot one person and ordered a firing squad to shoot three more in April 1916, later charged as guilty but insane.

Youth become judge and jury in century-old murder case

Young detectives change minds several times before coming up with final verdict

An old court case, a local man, an adolescent jury.

On July 20, 20 children, aged nine to 14, were presented with the facts of the century-old case of Captain J. C. Bowen-Colthurst.

Bowen-Colthurst was born in 1880 in Cork, Ireland, into an upper-class English-Anglican family.

He was given a superior education and entered the Royal Military College, where he graduated with honours and was commissioned into the 1st Royal Irish Rifles.

He fought in the Second Boer War, the Tibet Expedition, and World War I, and although young, Bowen-Colthurst quickly rose through the ranks to become captain.

Bowen-Colthurst was popular with his men, but he fell into disfavour with his superiors for his impulsive and crazed behaviour in the heat of battle. After being wounded in the Battle of Mons in World War I, Bowen-Colthurst was sent home to Ireland, where he was diagnosed as “mentally unstable” by his doctors.

It was at this time the Easter Uprising (a rebellion of the Irish against British rule in Ireland) occurred.

On the night of April 24, 1916, Captain Bowen-Colthurst was sent out from the Portobello Barracks in Dublin to investigate the house of a Mr. James Kelly, who was a suspected rebel leader.

Without cause or authority to do so, Bowen-Colthurst took a prisoner named Skeffington with him as a hostage.

On the way to the house of Mr. Kelly, the captain and his soldiers came across two youth, whom Bowen-Colthurst questioned. Then, for no apparent reason, Bowen-Colthurst abruptly shot one of the youth, the innocent 19-year-old J.J. Coade.

The detachment continued to the house of Mr. Kelly, who was absent at the time, and arrested two men found in the house, Mr. McIntyre and Mr. Dickson.

The next morning Captain Bowen-Colthurst ordered a guard to bring Skeffington, McIntyre and Dickson out into the yard for questioning.

As the guard sent off an inquiry, Bowen-Colthurst commanded a firing squad into the yard, where the three men were instantly shot dead.

None of them were involved in the rebellion and there was no coherent reason for their execution.

News of the events reached the Secretary of the State for War for England, who had Bowen-Colthurst arrested and court-martialed.

After being declared guilty but insane, Bowen-Colthurst was sent to Broadmoor Asylum for the Criminally Insane in the summer of 1916.

He stayed there until 1918, when public complaints, evidence of shell shock and temporary insanity, and numerous statements of his character warranted his conditional release.

With his reputation tarnished, Bowen-Colthurst travelled to Canada and had settled in Terrace by 1921.

When his wife and four kids joined him two years later, they lived in a house at Kitsumkalum. His wife, Linda, purchased 60 acres of land at Waterlily Bay, and the family owned a cabin there.

They lived off Bowen-Colthurst’s army pension and later moved to Sooke, BC.

Linda died in 1940, leaving her property on Lakelse Lake to her kids, and Bowen-Colthurst married again.

Until his death in 1965, he was an active member of his local communities.

•••••

On July 20 this year, the facts of the case were hidden around the site and the participants were sent out to gather the clues. Facts and testimonies were organized and a timeline of the events was assembled and then read out to the entire group.

Any questions were addressed before the facts were left to be further examined.

There were three possible verdicts explained—guilty, not guilty, and special verdict (an option in English law wherein the jury finds the defendant neither guiltless, nor wholly guilty)—and all participants wrote down their choice of verdict.

The first count was read out with the majority voting guilty, a few declaring not guilty, and only a handful pronouncing special verdict.

The kids were then asked to explain their reasoning, which some did in jest, while others presented sound arguments. Another vote took place with much of the same conclusions.

After another short discussion, the issue of Bowen-Colthurst’s alleged insanity was brought to light, and a few participants mentioned the overwhelming evidence of his suffering from Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD).

After another vote, special verdict held the majority, with a few still arguing the guilty side.

The divided group was then asked to come up with their best arguments to try to sway the other side.

PTSD, shock, and lack of awareness of reality, stemming from an unstable mental state, was mentioned for the special verdict side.

Inexcusable guilt and the absolute innocence of those killed supported the guilty verdict.

One participant asked for the rest to think about what verdict they would want if they had killed while not in complete control of their mind and body.

In the end, the room descended into slight chaos and the case was ended with the actual historic verdict of “guilty but insane” explained.

Twenty participants were given a real case with complex circumstances and they stepped up to the challenge.

Their thoughtful discussion on the subject of PTSD and its effects on mind, body, and society, revealed a very mature understanding of the subject and a readiness to discuss and debate.

The two final verdicts, special verdict and guilty, were both well thought out and their handling of the trial-by-jury format was sophisticated and compelling.

In a program built on local history, criminal justice and human fallibility, the youth of Terrace demonstrated their own ability in handling a difficult and sophisticated subject and situation.

Just Posted

Terrace RCMP arrest Kitimat man for drug trafficking

A police investigation has led to the arrest of a Kitimat man… Continue reading

Terrace Fire Department announces new training program, increased calls in year-end report

All firefighters in Terrace are expected to complete training by the end of April 2018.

UPDATE: Prince Rupert woman killed in logging truck collision

Empty logging truck west of Terrace struck moose before colliding with the eastbound SUV

David Edwardsen sentenced to eight years in jail

Sentencing result of 14 drug and firearms convictions

Taking a virtual walk across Canada

The Kermode Friendship Society challenged their staff to participate in this year’s competition, which aims to promote physical activity, networking, and friendly competition.

How to keep local news visible in your Facebook feed

Facebook has changed the news feed to emphasize personal connections. You might see less news.

VIDEO: Protesters rally for affordable housing ahead of B.C. budget

Residents call on province to keep locals housed

#Metoo movement causing confusion in many men, fear of missteps with women: experts

Being painted by the same sweeping brush as those alleged to have mistreated women has angered men

Liberals to dig deeper, aim higher on gender equality in 2018 federal budget

Finance Minister Bill Morneau said the budget would include measures to boost women in the workforce

Body of missing skier found

Man’s truck found in Revelstoke Mountain Resort’s parking lot covered in ‘several days’ snow’

Thrilling finish to 59th All Native Tournament

Kitamaat, Hydaburg, Port Simpson and Kitkatla win championships in 2018 All Native Tournament

B.C. VIEWS: Subsidy supercluster settles in B.C.

Ottawa, Victoria add to their overlapping ‘innovation’ budgets

Most Read